Studies show medication, physical therapy as effective as knee surgery

Posted: February 20, 2009 Author: Jennifer Walker-Journey Pharmaceutical

Two studies show that is beneficial at times but should not be performed routinely for the treatment of osteoarthritis, according to Fox News. The studies were published in a recent New England Journal of . One finds that medicine combined with physical therapy is just as effective as surgery for relieving the pain and stiffness of moderate or severe arthritis. The other study finds that tears in knee cartilage that often result in surgery are very common and do not always cause symptoms.

Osteoarthritis is a common aliment that has earned the condition a top ranking in disability of Americans. Symptoms of stiffness, pain and limited movement are caused when the cartilage at the end of the bone breaks down, causing the bones to rub together at the joints. The most common remedy has been arthroscopic surgery, during which surgeons insert a scope with a camera through small incisions, where they smooth damaged cartilage surfaces and flush out bone chips. This allows for faster healing time than traditional surgery.

To alleviate pain following knee surgery, doctors at times will insert a pain pump to deliver medication directly to the surgical wound site. These can help alleviate the pain associated with surgery, but they may come at a greater risk. Post-operative , or , are routinely used in similar arthroscopic surgeries for .

A recent study by The identified a link between the post-operative pain pumps and a painful, cartilage deteriorating condition known as Postarthoscopic Glenohumeral , or PAGCL. PAGCL can cause irreversible damage and may require additional surgeries.

Patients who are considering knee surgery are advised to discuss alternative options with their physicians.

Related posts:

  1. The pump that doesn’t ease the pain
  2. Pain pump malfunction saves officer’s right shoulder
  3. Shoulder surgery decision weighs on Rockies’ Jeff Francis
  4. Pain pump manufacturers named in lawsuit
  5. Health Canada issues warning about postoperative pain pumps
  • http://www.uch.edu/conditions/rehabilitation-therapy/physical-therapy/cu-sports-physical-therapy/ Colorado Physical Therapy

    I think this was a very interesting journal. But I think it is important to differentiate between two common types of surgeries for arthritis, i.e. arthroscopic Vs total knee replacement.

    As far as I'm aware total knee replacement have very good outcomes. I believe this journal was more comparing Physical Therapy Vs arthroscopic knee surgery.

  • Vern M.

    How fascinating and actually pretty unfortunate at the same time. I've known a lot of people who have had surgery on their back or lower extremities for the symptoms of osteoarthritis and in many cases the end result was worse than what they were dealing with before surgery! That they could have been put into a transitional physical therapy program and given pain medication instead is even worse, though, because they were never even given an option for that!

    • http://www.beasleyallen.com BeasleyAllen

      Thank you so much for your comment about the pain pumps. It really is
      terrible, isn't it, that something that is supposed to provide help and
      relief may end up making the problem worse, isn't it? I guess it really
      shows the importance of always trying to find as many options as
      possible on your own, and insisting on second opinions, before making
      any decisions. Thanks again for the comment!

      Wendi

  • http://www.blackchiropractic.com.au Dr David Black

    The concept of a pain pump makes sense.
    It would use very small doses of analgesic to control pain.
    As a pharmacist and chiropractor I endorse this wholeheartedly !
    Dr.David Black
    http://www.blackchiropractic.com.au

  • lilianhutan

    That honestly doesn't come as a shock because sometimes we rush into procedures that damage us for life. A strict documentation before making such an operation, like research of medical books, even a visit at an online pharmacy can reduce the risk factor.

  • annalisekaylor

    it's good job

  • http://www.airconditionersonline.in/forumdisplay.php?f=96 air conditioners prices

    hi, great blog! …,

  • Anonymous

    It is right that physical therapy effect on your knee so you should careful as in the case and simply exercise who keep good your lower back pain thanks for it.